To Hang or Not to Hang?

Today’s “This Day” post raises the question of whether John H. Winder—who was in charge of the Confederate prison system that included Andersonville—was a war criminal. He died before the surrender, but his subordinate, Henry Wirz, did hang.
Our entry on Winder does an evenhanded job, I think, of considering this prickly question:

Historians, meanwhile, have debated Winder’s culpability in the deaths of thousands of Union prisoners, both in Richmond and at Andersonville. On the one hand, the evidence suggests that although he was hampered by poor-quality prison guards, an inconsistent supply of food, and no central management of the Confederacy’s prison system, Winder attempted to treat prisoners well and, as commissary general, greatly reduced the death rate.
On the other hand, some historians argue that officials for both the Union and Confederacy were culpable for deliberately mistreating prisoners, either through physical punishment or the denial of adequate resources. The records not being entirely extant, the total number of prison deaths is difficult to calculate; however, the common figure is that 30,218 of 194,743 Union prisoners died in captivity. While a 15 percent mortality rate is high, it mirrors a 12 percent mortality rate among Confederate prisoners—25,976 Confederates died out of a total of 214, 865 prisoners. And these soldiers died despite the North experiencing no serious shortages of food or supplies. Either way, Winder appears to be a figure caught in the middle, implicated by his responsibility for so many deaths, vindicated—perhaps—by his efforts to avoid them.

IMAGE: Reading the death warrant to Henry Wirz on the scaffold; photograph by Alexander Gardner


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Sponsors  |  View all