Following the Battle of Antietam, which marked the bloodiest day of the war, Lee decided to pull his weariedback across the and into Virginia. On the night of September 18, Lee’s forces crossed the river at Boteler’s Ford, a mile south of Shepherdstown. Lee understood that this crossing was his army’s only escape route and, since September 16, had protected it with infantry in support of forty-four cannon, all under the command of William Nelson Pendleton. The morning after Lee’s crossing, September 19, McClellan sent cavalry under Alfred Pleasonton to reconnoiter. Directed by McClellan not to cross the Potomac “unless you see a splendid opportunity to inflict great damage upon the enemy without loss to yourself,” Pleasonton remained on the Maryland shore; the Confederate position guarding the ford appeared to be strong.
While Pleasonton remained on the Maryland side of the river, he directed his artillery to fire at Confederate positions across the Potomac. By late morning, Union general Fitz-John Porter’s Fifth Corps arrived to support Pleasonton with orders from McClellan to pursue the Confederates. Throughout the day, Union artillerymen dueled with their Confederate counterparts on the opposite shore, and at nightfall five hundred soldiers from Porter’s command crossed the Potomac and attacked Pendleton’s position. During the fight, Porter’s men captured five cannon and sent Pendleton into a panic.
Late that night Pendleton left his command to find support. Initially, he sought, but after failing to locate him, Pendleton searched for Lee. Around one o’clock in the morning on September 20, Pendleton found Lee and informed him, erroneously, that Union troops had seized all of his artillery.
Building on his earlier success, Porter sent four brigades across the Potomac into Virginia on
September 20. As his troops entered Shepherdstown, they met Confederate reinforcements from‘s command. Porter immediately ordered his men back to the Maryland shore, but some could not escape before Confederates from ‘s division opened fire. Among the regiments pinned down was the 118th Pennsylvania, which had never before seen combat. Lack of experience coupled with faulty muskets spelled disaster for this regiment. Union artillery and infantry fire allowed some of the troops to get to the Potomac’s Maryland bank, but many could not escape.
Increased Union artillery support throughout the day, however, forced Confederate commanders to seek cover for their men. As the day wore on, both sides remained in position and the Battle of Shepherdstown ended in a tactical stalemate with troops staring at each other across the Potomac.
After two days of fighting, Union and Confederate forces suffered a combined total of 677 casualties. Among that number were 269 casualties from the 118th Pennsylvania. Confederate protection of Boteler’s Ford convinced McClellan that Lee might attempt another invasion of Maryland. To block any Confederate advance, McClellan kept Porter’s entire Fifth Corps in position along the Potomac River until late October. While the Battle of Shepherdstown paralyzed McClellan and contributed further to Lincoln’s disgust over McClellan’s lack of aggressiveness, it saved the Army of Northern Virginia. With minimal sacrifice, Lee was able cross his army safely into the northern, where it could rest to fight another day.